Tag Archives: elections

Newham Hustings

13 May

A few images and a brief report from last night’s hustings at Brittania Village Hall.  You can read the live coverage of the event on Twitter.

2014 05 12 19 30 45

Labour’s only representative at the hustings was an empty chair.

2014 05 12 19 35 00

Chair John Stewart of HACAN East introduces the speakers – Lois Austin (TUSC), Caroline Allen (Green) and Stefen Mrozinski (Conservative). Out of shot next to Lois is Alex Ocan Latim of the Christian Peoples Alliance. Jonathan Fryer of the Liberal Democrats arrived late. The UKIP candidate for Mayor, David Mears, was unable to attend for personal reasons.

2014 05 12 21 18 57

TUSC’s Lois Austin says her party is the true inheritor of the East End’s Labour tradition; they are an alternative to the cuts and austerity policies that unite the established parties. On transport she calls for more investment in public transport, lower fares and the re-nationalisation of the trains and buses. She promises to be a workers’ mayor on a workers’ wage and accuses Newham Labour of turning its back on the poor, failing them on housing and local services. As there’s no Labour representative on the panel her charges go unanswered.

2014 05 12 21 23 05

Caroline Allen of the Green Party, number two on their London list for the European parliament, makes the case for a social Europe and a London that works for people, not just big business. Inequality is a massive issue for her party. She calls for rent controls and investment in cycling and walking, rather than building ever more roads, bridges and tunnels. There are huge public health benefits to be had, she says.

Screenshot 2014 05 13 08 49 37

Tory mayoral candidate Stefan Mrorzinski rejects expansion of City Airport and says the social costs – pollution and the impact on local businesses – are too high. He attacks Robin Wales’s record after 20 years in power: poor school results, no improvement in poverty, high crime levels and anti-social behaviour. There has been a huge waste of public money on the Newham Mag, Building 1000, London Pleasure Gardens etc. He says he opposes Boris Johnson on building more & more tower blocks & ‘buy to leave’ investment properties: “we need to build streets, not tower blocks.” He says the mayoral system has failed here as Labour’s 60 councillors are failing to hold Sir Robin to account: Newham needs an opposition.

Screenshot 2014 05 13 11 43 17

Alex Ocan Latim of the Christian Peoples Alliance wants to refurbish empty local houses and build new low cost homes for low earning families. Newham owns land, so it should build low cost housing on it. It seems even the Christians are to the left of Labour in Newham! Alex is also deeply concerned about creating local jobs and opportunities for young people.

Screenshot 2014 05 13 11 44 14

For the Liberal Democrats, European candidate Jonathan Fryer is forced to defend his party’s record in in the coalition government after attacks from TUSC and the Greens. He agrees on the need for more affordable public transport and improved rail use as an alternative to airport expansion. Oddly, he doesn’t mention the white elephant of Stratford International, but when it is raised he – and everyone else – agrees it is vital to get international services started as quickly as possible. As a European rather than local candidate he makes his pitch for a positive vision for the EU. “Don’t be sucked in by that funny Mr Farage. Vote for progress,” he says.

It was an entertaining evening and the debate was good-natured. There were no clear winners among the parties that attended, but one very obvious loser. And you don’t need me to tell you who that was – just look for the empty seat.

Never gonna be respectable

12 May

Respect Tory

There is an old saying that the older you get, the more right-wing your politics become.

If that’s true there’s a bunch of former Respect candidates on day release from the geriatric ward.

Having stood in 2010 for the George Galloway fan club Abdul Karim Sheikh (Green St West), Abul Mohshin Kazi (Plaistow North), Ashfaq Ahmed and Kamran Qureshi (both Green St East) are all now Conservative party candidates for Newham council.

I assume the Tories knew their political histories when they selected them. Which either tells you a lot about the state of Newham Conservative party and its desperate desire to run a full slate, or a lot about the ideological flexibility of the candidates.

Of course these four aren’t the only ones who have moved to the right in search of electoral success.

Former Respect councillor and 2008 London Assembly candidate Hanif Abdulmuhit (Green St West) is now wearing a Newham Labour rosette, along with Forhad Hussain (Plaistow North), who is a rising star in Sir Robin’s administration and has already ascended to cabinet rank.

Missing in action

12 May

Here’s ten words that you won’t find anywhere in Newham Labour’s “groundbreaking” manifesto:

  • Collaboration
  • Co-operation (nor cooperative)
  • Engagement
  • Transformation
  • Digital (nor even ‘online’)
  • Teachers
  • Workers (except in the guise of ‘hard-working families’)
  • Justice
  • Equality
  • Union
Also missing, though less of a surprise given Sir Robin’s True Blue politics, is Socialism.

An analysis of the Newham Labour manifesto

9 May

I am grateful to a reader for providing the following analysis of Newham Labour’s priorities and comparing them to ideas sourced from across the community.

Priorities indicated by proportion of writing in the manifesto:

 Priority Pages of text   Number of promises  
Increasing personal resilience ½  9% 2 11%
Tackling crime and anti-social behaviour 1 18% 4 22%
Working for a cleaner, greener Newham ¼  5% 1 6%
Making Newham better through investment  2¾  50% 7 39%
Standing up for Newham 1 18% 4 22%
  5 ½    18  

Issues that could have been in the manifesto, based on suggestions from local Labour candidate websites, newspapers, community groups & charities and residents on social media:

Issue Mentioned? Policies/ principles Promises
Fairness and help for vulnerable people    


Children Yes, p4 Inclusive education  
Homeless No None  
Elderly Yes, p9 One promise 14: fully fund the Freedom Pass providing free travel on public transport including buses, Tube, train and Docklands Light Railway.
Black and Ethnic Minorities No None  
Disabled people No None  
Religious groups No None  
Mentally ill No None  
Women Yes, p6 Assess the approach to domestic and sexual violence   
LGBT No None  
Development of community cohesion No None  
Approach to dealing with the bedroom tax No None   


Working with the MPS Yes, p5 Funded 46 police officers, 140 enforcement officers

will continue to work on initiatives with local police and other partners to support victims and reduce repeat crimes

promise 2: continue to fund and control police officers

promise 3: assess initiatives to reduce crime

Tackle anti-social behaviour Yes, p5 residents feel safer when CCTV cameras are used in areas where there are safety risks


promise 4: tackle crime and anti-social behaviour, 

promise 5: dedicated enforcement officer in each ward

promise 6: Invest £5million in 200 new CCTV cameras

Tackling hate crimes No None  
Support anti-burglary measures No None  
Educate and support tackling violent/knife crime No None  
Environment   In all our surveys residents say they want a cleaner, greener and safer Newham  
Street cleaning Yes, p4 £13.5million spent annually

Free bulky waste removal


promise 7: £4m to improve roads, pavement & lighting
Improve responsiveness to reports of dumped waste No None  
Parks and green spaces No None  
Green issues Yes None  
Increasing recycling No None  
Introduce car share schemes No None  
Resist expansion of City Airport No None  
Supporting more schools and markets achieving eco awards No None  
Tackling air pollution No None  


Free school meals Yes, p8 Free school meals for primary school children,  promise 9: continue free school meals for primary school children; 
Introducing Food for Life standards in schools No None  
Educational achievement Yes, p8 Every child a musical instrument & free tuition, free try of 20 sports, 1:1 reading tuition, every child a chess player

work with our schools to continue the excellent improvements in exam results

New 6th form college in East Ham

promise 9: continue with the Newham’s Every Child a Musician programme giving 3 years free tuition, continue with the Newham’s Every Child a Sports Person programme giving the opportunity to try 20 different sports 
Literacy Yes, p8   promise 9: Newham Reading Guarantee programme providing 1:1 tuition to younger children struggling to read.
Improving digital skills of all generations  No  None  
Skills for employment Yes, p9   promise 10: review skills training offered to adults and children
Improve adult education Yes, p9 Free English speaking classes promise 11: provide free English language tuition for all residents who want to learn English.
Ensuring teachers are qualified No None  
Resisting academies & free schools No None  
Tackling bulling and inequality in schools No None   
Summer schools No None   


Unemployment Yes, p7 Helped 20,000 into work including 3,500 young people  promise 8: continue to invest heavily in Workplace
Money Yes, p8 provide some finance options for responsible, hard working residents promise 12: set up a one stop shop – Money Works – which will provide a range of support to responsible residents
Council tax Yes, p4 Means to keep lowest council tax in outer London promise 1: has delivered the lowest Council Tax in Outer London and means to keep it.
Support refugees and asylum seekers No None  
Food banks, food cycling No None  
Supporting food planting on estates, in parks and in gardens No None  
Supporting living wage (council) Yes, p11 ensures that it pays all its directly employed staff the London Living Wage. As a Borough which has retained most of its services in-house this makes us a leader, if not the leader, in this battle promise 17: continue to pay the London Living Wage and review rates of pay offered by contractors.
Supporting living wage (local employers) No None  
Not use workfare or zero hours contracts (council)  No None  
Discourage use of workfare and zero hours contracts (local employers) No None  
Tackle fuel poverty, home insulation, excess winter deaths No None  
Reducing gambling Yes, p10 led the country in our opposition to betting shops. We are demanding the powers to limit the fixed odds betting terminals which have caused the explosion in betting shops. We are not opposed to gambling – people should be free to pursue those pastimes which they enjoy – but not at a cost to other people. These new betting shops attract crime and anti social behaviour. That is why we will fight to get them off our high streets.  
Supporting time banks No None  
Supporting good quality, affordable childcare No None  
Providing secure bike racks No None  
Public health   Yes, p9  Support into employment, primary school meals, personal resilience, reviewing the spend on public health, developing personal budgets for individuals so they can have greater control of the services they consume, payments scheme which will financially reward service providers where users show high satisfaction with their services. promise 13: continue to support the development of personal resilience; will develop a model where payment is linked to satisfaction for those who use our caring services. 
Hospitals Yes, p10 ensure our hospital stays open and that the facilities there are the right ones for our people. 

ensure that the full range of quality health services are available to our residents and, in particular, that they have easy access to an effective and comprehensive screening programme.

promise 18: stand up proudly for our residents against Tory attacks, fighting for the things that matter to them while also delivering services which make a difference.
GPs No None  
Tackle high rates of TB and deaths from cancer No None  
Free fitness classes and equipment in parks No None  
Introduce a responsible licensing scheme No None  
Introduce a take away food licensing scheme No None  
Regeneration & Enterprise Yes, p10 continue to invest secure funding and help to deliver the physical infrastructure of the borough such as:

Redeveloping Canning Town and Custom House

created nearly 9,000 new school places and invested £127 million into our schools

Buying 35% of the Olympic Stadium to ensure that it works for local people in the future (and generates a profit)

Assisted securing cycle superhighway extensions, Greenway investment and new quiet routes making Newham a much better place to cycle

Rebuilding the Atherton Leisure Centre

Created a brand new library and local service centre in East Ham

Started on the development of a new 6th form college at East Ham in partnership with our schools

Secure Westfield, the largest urban shopping centre in Western Europe

Regeneration of Queen’s market No    
Regeneration of Forest Gate No    
Support for street markets No    


Private renters Yes, p11   promise 15: continue to reduce anti-social behaviour and improve accommodation in the private rented sector by licensing all privately rented property.
Implementing a good letting agent scheme No None  
Support for home owners/ leaseholders No None  
House building Yes, p10   promise 16: within the next ten years, build 3,000 new homes and buy a further 500 which will be made available for local people to rent at a range of rents that suit their income.
Tackling overcrowding No None  
Tackling homelessness and supporting homeless people No None  
Social homes for rent (council or housing association) No None  
Responsive to local needs Yes, p5 we have increased spend on the things that matter most to our residents.  
Reducing complaints No None  
Involving residents in designing services Yes, p4 where there really is a caring task we will develop new

small-scale mutuals to offer a much better, person focussed

offer through greater clarity of purpose.

Involving residents in working together with the council to provide services No None  


Tackling congestion on buses and trains No None  
Improving cycling safety No None  
Managing parking and drop off points at stations No None  
Creating safe passing places for cars on small roads  No None  
River Crossing consultation No None  
Managing budget cuts Yes, p4   promise 2: will protect the services residents value in the face of the most savage cuts ever to local government in general and Newham in particular.
Management/ consultation on cuts of £41m (2015/16) and £53m (2015/16) No None  
Reducing council spending on councillors, offices, events, communications No None  
Tackling duplication, corruption, fraud and waste No None  
Arts and events Yes, p9 We invested heavily to encourage local celebration and activity from street parties to torch relay. 

Buying 35% of the Olympic Stadium to ensure that it works for local people in the future (and generates a profit)

 Arts, festivals, events No None  

Verging on the ridiculous

9 May

The late Guardian journalist Simon Hoggart coined the phrase “the law of the ridiculous reverse”, which states that if the opposite of a statement is plainly absurd, it was not worth making in the first place.

It is entertaining to apply this to some of the statements in Newham Labour’s election manifesto. For example:

Labour will do the best we can to protect the services residents value

Would any party promise the opposite? They might win points for honesty but not many votes.

Or how about this:

Labour will continue to fully assess the effectiveness of all initiatives designed to reduce crime and will act appropriately to make them more effective.

The thought of the mayor promising to abandon assessment, act inappropriately and deliberately make crime reduction initiatives less effective is amusing but absurd. 

Labour will … ensure that our young people and adults are provided with greater and better choice.

As opposed to offering lesser and worse choices perhaps?

There are many others to choose from, but this one is my favourite:

we are reviewing the spend on public health to make sure that the money is targeted effectively on programmes which actually make a difference

And there I was expecting a promise to throw public money around like a drunk sailor on shore leave without regard to the consequences!

Talking of promises…

8 May

Vote Green 2014

The London Green Party is launching its campaign for the European and local elections today. 

You can read their manifesto for Europe and find out more about their local candidate for mayor, Jane Lithgow.

It is inconceivable that Jane will beat Sir Robin, but a vote for her would not be a waste. Every vote for another candidate is a vote for a different kind of politics in Newham; a vote that says there are other voices that deserve to be heard.

The European election is, unlike the local vote, proportional. Whoever you vote for, your vote will count towards electing an MEP that speaks for you.

Mapping the candidates

7 May

Where the candidates live

Where do the candidates for mayor and council live?

You can see the whole map, including the colour key for the pins, on Batchgeo

The winner takes it all

6 May

Agnetha is sad

Agnetha is sad because her vote in the Newham council election will be wasted

If history is any guide, on 22 May the Labour party in Newham will win about 65% of the vote and 100% of the seats on the council.

Sir Robin and his band of merry men (and those closest to him are all men) will celebrate a great victory and carry on exactly as before.

The 35% who didn’t vote Labour will again have no voice and no representation. Sir Robin will face no tough questions, no challenge and no scrutiny from anyone who doesn’t already agree with him.

Does it really have to be this way?

As long ago as 1913 the Independent Labour Party, forerunner of today’s Labour party, argued that

“No system of election can be satisfactory which does not give opportunity to all parties to obtain representation in proportion to their strength.”

In January the Electoral Reform Society published Towards One Nation – the Labour Case for Electoral Reform [link downloads a PDF]. The report argues that by tolerating electoral deserts – places like Newham where there are no Tories, Lib Dems or Greens; as well as places where Labour itself has no voice – the party “is colluding in alienating people from political activity.”

Parties only have limited resources of finance and activism, and people understandably grow tired of throwing their money, time and effort at a hopeless cause. The more committed activists may be willing to travel to campaign in a marginal seat, but most people prefer to be active in their own community. 

In Newham, I doubt this argument holds much sway. Who cares if the opposition are demoralised and frustrated? All the better for us! 

But Sir Robin should beware.

Effectively locking a proportion of voters out of representation is bad not only on democratic grounds, but because the withering of opposition does not produce more wholesome politics.

Although Newham has so far been resistant to the far-right, you only need to look to what happened in Barking and Dagenham in 2006 to see the consequences of a complacent and neglectful Labour party with no traditional opposition voices: the election of 12 BNP councillors.

There is also the matter of good governance. As executive mayor Sir Robin has free rein over almost every significant area of policy. All that keeps him in check is oversight and scrutiny from councillors. But where all of those councillors come from the same party, what hope is there for genuine accountability? We know from experience the answer is ‘none.’ 

For 2014 we are stuck with ‘first past the post’ and the continuation of a one-party state. But a Labour government elected in 2015 could change things. And there is hopeful precedent:

Whenever the opportunity has arisen, Labour has recognised the importance of choosing fairer voting systems over First Past the Post. The first Blair government made a positive choice to endow new democratic institutions – both the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly – with electoral systems considerably fairer than Westminster’s. And in 2007 a Labour-led coalition introduced the Single Transferable Vote (STV) for local elections in Scotland.

Local government in England struggles with a huge democratic deficit: fewer than half the electorate bothers to vote;  councils that should be the closest to and most engaged political institution with their communities seem remote; and there is little space for new and interesting voices.

The system is ripe for democratic reform and in Newham the need is urgent.

Fair and balanced

2 May

Despite the election, the council website continues to promote Sir Robin and his fellow Labour candidates

The small handful of residents that actually open the Newham Mag will have been surprised that the past two editions have been entirely free from pictures of Sir Robin Wales. This is because election rules require public authorities not to do anything that would appear to favour one candidate or party over another.

Strangely, that memo doesn’t seem to have reached the editor of the council website. The homepage continues to display a prominent picture of Sir Robin next to the caption ‘Meet the Mayor’. Clicking through takes you to a page with four more pictures of him.

The latest news section has a carousel of five pictures at the top, two of which feature the mayor. The picture accompanying the ‘Every OAP a ping-pong player’ story (shown above) also features several prominent Labour candidates for council.

But the council website is relatively restrained compared to the Newham Recorder. As an independent publication it is not bound by the election rules that constrain the Mag.

The three editions since the election was formally announced have featured Wales’ picture ten times. He’s been mentioned in stories sixteen times; the other candidates have been mentioned just once each, in a list.

The most recent edition even included a lengthy opinion piece by Sir Robin on why it is important we should vote, accompanied by a large photo of the man himself, just to remind you who it is you are meant to vote for.

The Recorder has pulled out all the stops to ensure maximum coverage for the man they know will be signing off the council’s advertising budgets for the next four years.

There’s nothing illegal about what the Recorder is doing, but readers are entitled to ask where the coverage is of the other candidates? If it’s important that we vote – and it is, it really is – then it’s vitally important that we make a properly informed choice.

Besides Sir Robin there are Tory, Liberal Democrat, Green, UKIP, Trade Unionist & Socialist Coalition, Communities United & Christian Peoples Alliances candidates for mayor. That’s quite a range of choices. Doesn’t the Recorder think its readers deserve proper coverage of all mayoral candidates, including opinion columns & pictures?

Local newspaper publishers have been vocal in calling for central government to get tough on council newspapers like the Newham Mag, which they characterise as ’town hall Pravdas’. Their case is undermined when supposedly independent papers like the Recorder fail to be, er, independent.

In the US the utterly biased right-wing ‘news’ channel Fox News has long used the slogan ‘fair and balanced’ to describe itself. The Newham Recorder should consider adopting it too.

Hat-tip to Mike Law for the stats on the Recorder’s coverage

A conversation with Hanif Abdulmuhit

29 Apr

Frustratingly WordPress won’t display embedded Storify content, so you’ll have to click the link below.